Power Levels

PlayEDH seeks to provide a game experience through curated power levels. We currently recognize five power levels: Battlecruiser (BC), Low Power (LOW), Mid Power (MID), High Power (HIGH), and Competitive EDH (cEDH). In each of our power levels, in any given pod, with checked decks, you should have a roughly even chance of winning. By providing you with deck checks to help determine where your list fits in our power levels, we strive to provide the best curated gameplay experience for EDH online. Our ultimate goal is balanced pods. Our power level system is our Rule Zero. As a note, cEDH follows a slightly different manner of curation. Please see this page for more information.

Magic is a complex game, so expect to encounter card interactions, synergy and game strategies that you might not be aware of. Not every deck that exists is immediately suited for these power levels; that is by design. We may ask you to make adjustments to better fit our power level structure. Decks will often play better on our platform when they are built with a specific power level in mind. Our power level guidelines are to be interpreted in the context of the full deck, and not applied verbatim.  If your deck is doing something that violates the general spirit of one of these power levels while not necessarily breaking a specific rule, a change may still be required to make the deck fit into a power level.

As it is a scale, we don’t intend for levels to be mixed and decks will ever only fit into a singular power level. Battlecruiser decks should not be played in Low Power, and High decks should not be played in Mid Power for example. Notably this idea goes both ways, and being a ‘speedbump’ is as undesirable as ‘pubstomping’. Where pubstomping is taking a deck that cannot be meaningfully interacted with into lower power games, being a speedbump is taking a deck that cannot interact or apply pressure in a meaningful way into higher power games.

Winning or losing in one power level is not an indicator to play outside of that power level without adjustment to the deck itself. No power level is worse than another, and all are valid ways to play the format. If a deck is checked to fit a power level, it can play in that power level, and it should expect the other decks playing in the same power level to play at about the same speed and consistency.

Restricted Cards

The following cards and combinations are banned at the following power levels and their curated LFG queues:

  • Gaea’s Cradle: Mid Power, Low Power, Battlecruiser

  • Thassa’s Oracle + Demonic Consultation and/or Tainted Pact: High Power, Mid Power, Low Power, Battlecruiser
    While you can play Thassa’s Oracle or Demonic Consultation/Tainted Pact as a card, you cannot combine these into the easy to execute combo outside of cEDH.

  • Negan, the Cold-Blooded: All power levels and all LFG queues. Malik, Grim Manipulator, the in-universe printing of this card is allowed. Secret Lair TWD was the first Universes Beyond product released, which was scrutinised by the larger EDH community. Several people from our community voiced being uncomfortable with the depiction of Negan in the format.

Power Level Basics

Preconstructed decks power levels:

Almost all preconstructed decks (precons) are battlecruiser by default.
Below is a list of ‘specialty’ product releases that got deck checked individually.

Secret Lair Drop: Heads I Win, Tails You Lose - Okaun//Zndrsplt - Low Power
Secret Lair Drop: From Cute to Brute - Esika, God of the Tree - Battlecruiser
Secret Lair Drop: Angels: They're Just Like Us but Cooler and with Wings - Gisela // Bruna - Low Power
Secret Lair Drop: Raining Cats and Dogs - Rin and Seri - Low Power

Deckbuilding Considerations

Some decks are constructed in such a way that they have interactions that over- or under-perform compared to the rest of the deck. For example, you have an Oona, Queen of the Fey Faerie focused deck that could fit in Low Power, but you also included a Demonic Consultation and Thassa's Oracle combo line, an overperforming combo that we restrict to cEDH only. Just because the combo is present, doesn’t mean the deck should play in the cEDH queue and taking out the combo is the correct course of action. Additionally, decks that are intended for play in a certain power level may have some of the building blocks for a power level but lack appropriate wincons, interaction, and consistency needed to perform at the power level it’s closest to. In that case, tuning up so the deck as a whole is more in line with it’s closest power level is the logical thing to do.

A deck will always get checked towards the least amount of changes that need to happen, should your deck not fit into a power level as-is. Comments left by the team in regards to your deck check will always be made towards the easiest build path. If your deck is 99% in line with our power level structure but has a card we won’t allow at that power level — A decently built Mid Power deck with a Gaea’s Cradle, for example — the correct action to take here is to cut the Gaea’s Cradle and replace it with something less potent. This doesn’t mean the deck should be ‘High Power with changes’, it makes it a Mid Power deck requiring a singular card swap.

Power Levels FAQ

Battlecruiser

Q: What do Battlecruiser decks look like?
Other than regular precons, BC decks usually share similar play patterns. Develop the board in the first few turns, deploy commander or threat, use combat as the primary means of interacting with your opponents, occasionally interacting with spot removal, wraths, and counterspells. Due to the nature of most decks and threats in BC, a high density of interaction is not essential, but it is still important that you run some. A good rule of thumb, run as much as a regular precon. A deck that specifically tries to undermine the creature oriented nature of BC can often create non-games and is generally something that won't get approved for play by the team. Some examples include, but are not limited to: Enchantment Prison, "Turbo fog", and "Punisher" type decks.

Q: What types of strategies are often too strong for Battlecruiser?
It is difficult to qualify exactly, but in general, strategies that directly attack building boardstates, preventing creature combat based interactions, and aggressive resource denial are usually if not always inappropriate for the power level. In the power level where precons are the rough baseline of power, a deck with 20 boardwipes will be an obvious poor fit, for example, disregarding the other strategies or building blocks present in the deck.

Q: Is Battlecruiser all about budget decks?
There are probably more budget-friendly lists getting played in Battlecruiser than in the other power levels. With the increase in global EDH popularity, a lot of ‘best in slot’ staples all shot up in price. Due to the (lack of) speed and need to optimize a deck and ‘push it towards how fast and strong it can be’, a Battlecruiser deck tends to be less expensive than a deck playing at a higher power level. BC decks can get away with playing some tapped lands for colorfixing, 3 or 4 cmc mana rocks over the 2 mana staples, a less optimal interaction package and/or a less commonly run theme with less ‘globally desired’ cards. This does not mean a BC deck playing ‘expensive cards’ is no longer BC, so long the rest of the structure of the deck still follows the regular BC guidelines. Playing ‘expensive’ cards is not something that should get ostracized on the server, be that in BC or any other power level.

Q: Is Battlecruiser just decks with bad cards, or badly designed decks?
Not really. Quantifying what a ‘bad card’ is will on it’s own already be difficult. Grizzly Bears in a vacuum won’t be a great card, but can be good synergy in decks with Ayula or Ruxa at the helm. You would expect to see Swords to Plowshares in a more competitive deck, but you also wouldn’t be surprised to see it in a Battlecruiser game. Precons often get desired reprints in them, and most cards are desired because they’re ‘good’ cards that haven’t been reprinted in a while. We still expect your deck to function in terms of ramp, interaction, synergy and game plan. ‘My deck has 65 lands and every spell is 6 mana or more’, is not the type of deck we expect people in Battlecruiser to be playing with or against.

Q: I upgraded my precon. Is it still Battlecruiser?
In most cases, yes. Many regular precon commanders have easy combo potential, or other ways in the 99 to enable simple combos. Doing your best to avoid these will help in your overall upgrades. ‘I just changed 5 cards to my precon’ might as well have added 5 game winning combo lines or loops to your deck. While you have plenty of room to upgrade precons and still be BC, those upgrades should still be in line with the general power level of BC as a whole. A boxed precon with 3 cards changed to create deliberate combo lines, means you have a BC deck with 3 problematic cards we’d ask you to remove. It doesn’t make it a Low power deck.

Q: Can I play [Specific Commander] in Battlecruiser?
Short answer: yes. Long answer: this depends on the deck. There are some commanders that offer very easy pathways to snowball while requiring very few deckbuilding drawbacks. ‘Neutering’ these commanders to be in line with Battlecruiser is possible, but oftentimes requires a very strong understanding of the power level and might result in a deck that doesn’t have the lines of play or synergy you were hoping for. No commander is inherently banned from a power level, but including the most commonly played value-engines or payoffs in tandem with said commander are usually a quick way to overshoot for BC.

Q: Any creature type focused deck is fine, right?
Oftentimes. A few types, including, but not limited to, Elves, Goblins, Zombies, Vampires, Gods, and Dragons, all have either incredibly powerful synergies or card quality that can make them very difficult to deal with. We often see precons printed with a limited amount of lord and anthem effects, and homebrew Battlecruiser decks should follow that trend.

Q: My deck got checked for Low but isn’t winning in Low. Can I try it out in Battlecruiser?
No. If you feel your deck got checked for an incorrect power level, open a ticket through our Modmail system on our Discord server so your deck can be looked at again by members of our team that specialize in one or several power levels.

Q: Can I play tutors in Battlecruiser?
Yes, but typically it's best to avoid the most efficient ones (Worldly, Vampiric, etc.). The pattern of games in BC does not require that you include hyper-efficient tutors to establish your board. ‘What can you tutor for’ also gets looked at by our team when they check your deck. It’s OK for your deck to have a Diabolic Tutor, but what card do we expect you to find with it? We’ll always assume the most optimal choice. Deliberately sandbagging or ‘I’ll keep the tutor/combo in there, I just won’t play it optimally’ are the wrong mindset to take to Battlecruiser, or any game played on our platform.

Q: Can I play Group Hug in Battlecruiser?
Yes. What you cannot do is play for second place. That includes making deck building considerations that are focused around you running enough interaction not to accidentally kingmake. Most people tend to dislike one player elevating another player ‘because they’re behind’. This does not mean you can’t politic or help another player out in an attempt to sway their behavior in your favor for a future turn as a political deal, but decks designed specifically ‘to make another person win’ don’t provide a play experience most people on our platform enjoy.

Group Hug can on accident accelerate a deck to a speed where it leads to an advantage for one person more than others. Doubling everyone’s mana will matter less to someone hard casting regular spells from hand, but will accelerate the other person at the table playing X spells or Hydra’s, for example.

Q: Can I play Chaos decks in Battlecruiser?
To a degree. You still have to take into account you’re trying to force Magic to work on a digital platform with 4 people sitting at 4 different locations, connected over webcam and voice communications. You shouldn’t play a bunch of cards that exist solely to create a messy game state people can no longer figure out ‘because it’s funny!’. Cards like Scrambleverse, Warp World or Aminatou’s final ability can be less than desireable to resolve when other people don’t have physical access to each others cards. Self-expression is important and we don't want people building decks just to mess up everyone else's experience.

Q: Can I play alternative wincons in Battlecruiser?
Yes, cards like Approach of the Second Sun or attempting to win via high life totals are fine, but the whole deck should not be full of cards that ensure you need to be removed from the game before you untap. In BC, a deck seeking to win via Approach of the Second Sun shouldn’t be supported by a large amount of wheels or card draw. Running Felidar Sovereign as a wincon likely shouldn’t be backed up by damage negating effects or cards like Teferi’s Protection.

Low Power

Q: What do Low Power decks look like?
Low decks generally have a degree of focus around a specific strategy or synergy and a defined way to close out the game. While the general card quality of ramp, draw, and interaction will on average be lower than what’s found in Mid, some powerful cards will appear in this level.  In general, strategies that tend to be too overwhelming for Battlecruiser, but which would typically struggle in Mid, should find a home in Low.  As in Mid, early turns are spent developing a board.  Interaction should still be present at this level, but the general pacing of the game is slower, allowing more time to draw into that interaction.

Q: I upgraded my precon. Is it Low?
Possibly. Most preconstructed Commander decks have a split focus and mixed card quality. While swapping just a handful of cards won’t consistently move a precon up to Low, in some cases it can. For example, the Kalamax precon can very easily be upgraded to support spell-copy combos that would not be allowed in BC, while the deck would need significantly more changes to make it into Mid. This type of change can easily move a precon closer to Low, but the ramp, interaction, draw and land base will be expected to also follow suit in regards to upgrades. Similarly, simply tuning the precon to be more focused on a single strategy or set of synergies, or improving the card quality can be examples of ways to possibly move a precon into Low.

Q: Can I play [Specific Commander] in Low?
Not all Commanders are created equal, and some will automatically generate more value than others. The context of the full deck defines the power level, and excessive-value Commanders may need additional downgrades or limitations to keep the overall deck in Low.

Q: Any creature type focused deck is fine, right?
Decks focusing on one type generally require support cards, and some types can generate overwhelming synergistic value. While Low will likely be the appropriate level for many creature type decks, not all of these decks will likely be Low by default.

Q: Can I play tutors in Low?
Yes. Typically the number and/or quality of tutors will be somewhat limited in Low, as the intent of Low is to provide a slower pace. Decks that are not tutoring for combo pieces or where combos are more complicated may have additional leeway in the number and quality of tutors.

Q: Can I play Group Hug in Low?
Yes, but be aware that “Kingmaking”, the practice of intentionally enabling other players to win rather than enabling yourself to win, is still disallowed.  You should have a plan to take advantage of your group hug effects to “break parity” as compared to what your opponents receive, and you should have a way to actually win the game.

Q: Is Low power just slower Mid decks?
No. Kind of. No. Low got created initially as a power level in 2021 to primarily fill the gap between Battlecruiser and Mid.  With the extreme growth of the server over the last few years, the number of decks which fell into this gap had been growing significantly.  Low was originally created to provide a home for these decks, and to avoid the problems of BC-pubstomping and Mid-speedbumping, and has over time taken more shape as it’s own dedicated power level.

Q: Is Low power just bad Mid decks?
No. Low fills the gap between Battlecruiser and Mid. Low power allows for a smoother transition as decks are upgraded, and provides better options for the team to place decks in power levels that help ensure that games of checked decks played on PlayEDH stay consistently fun.  After all, that’s the entire purpose of the curated experience we strive for here.  “Low” power does not in any way imply that decks in that power level are “bad,” simply that they play at a different pace than Mid but have a higher general level of card quality/focus/synergy than decks that can reasonably play against preconstructed decks or other Battlecruiser lists.

Q: Why is the power level called ‘Low power’?
We initially thought ‘Low’ sounded a little negative, but we already had Mid and High power on the server. A lot of names were considered, and Low was the one that stuck around. We didn’t want to convolute our system with more ‘special’ or ‘made up’ words, and seeing BC, Low, Mid, High, cEDH is more clear to new people from the get go.

Mid Power

Q: What do Mid Power decks look like?
Mid decks are focused around one or more specific wincons, and are built to support their main strategies. Efficient ramp and interaction, strong manabases and fixing, and powerful individual card quality are all present here. Early turns spent developing a board, or leaving interaction open are common. While you will usually not be required to prevent players from winning in early turns, expect your opponents to be developing  towards their focused wins or establishing strong value engines, so having the ability to interact or apply pressure so the table collectively can manage itself is important. Your decks need to be able to do those things.

Q: I upgraded my Low deck. Is it Mid?
The path from Low to Mid usually involves more than a few simple card upgrades; upgrades that change the power level of a deck typically involve changing win conditions, adding/improving tutors, and associated changes to support those improvements. Simply upgrading one aspect of a deck will not always make the entire deck appropriate for a different power level.

Q: Can I play [Specific Commander] in Mid?
Sure, but the rest of your deck begins to matter a lot more than just commander selection here. If your deck needs your commander to function at all, you should seek to have replacement cards and effects in place for situations where your commander gets put under an opponent’s control or gets removed to a point recasting it is no longer feasible mana wise, and run appropriate interaction. Your commander getting removed shouldn’t mean you’re going to twiddle your thumbs for several turns.

Q: Any creature type focused deck is fine, right?
At the end of the day, many creature types will require a lot of support from staple cards to buoy those types that do not have as much synergy. It’s probably easier to make a strong Goblin deck than it is to make Turtle deck.

Q: Can I play tutors in Mid?
Yes, and you probably should. Your opponents will be.

Q: Can I play Group Hug in Mid?
Yes. What you cannot do is play for second place. That includes making deck building considerations that are focused around you running enough interaction not to accidentally kingmake. Accelerants need to be leveraged first and foremost by you, not the player who untaps after you. Consider Group Hug to be like reverse-stax: the hug deck is altering the resources available in the game, and should be built to asymmetrically take advantage of those extra resources.

Don't accelerate for the sake of acceleration; your deck should be accelerating faster than everyone else, and your deck should be prepared to stop your opponents from taking too much advantage of the extra resources. Amplifying one resource while restricting another can help accomplish this - for example, providing extra mana but only giving extra cards to yourself, with a healthy amount of interaction. Hugs let you fly under the threat radar, but without special care, you'll just give the player in the most advantageous position fuel to win.

High Power

Q: What do High Power decks look like?
High power decks are decks that are tuned beyond what is appropriate for Mid with less-telegraphed win conditions, faster mana, more efficient interaction, and more general focus on more resilient/redundant win conditions. Win conditions are efficient, protected, less telegraphed, and have solid backup plans. High decks may feature strategies as compact as a single card that creates a game winning synergy with their commander.

High decks aren't able to compete with cEDH decks, even when they are fully optimized themselves. However, these lists can still share many of the same hyper-efficient cards, accelerations, interactions, and wincons. Assume that players will be aiming to win, establish some form of lock, or gain momentous advantage from early points in the game. Players will be playing disruption, removal, and static hate pieces to try and stop you from winning.

Q: Sounds like it's just cEDH. What's the difference?
High allows for decks that are too fast or oppressive for Mid, but too slow or inconsistent for cEDH. Many play patterns are similar, and there is an emphasis on justifying card selection. If your deck is a few card choices off from a cEDH deck, here on the server, just proxy them up for webcam games and head to cEDH. High and cEDH are separate environments.